Go4Expert

Go4Expert (http://www.go4expert.com/)
-   Engineering Concepts (http://www.go4expert.com/forums/engineering-concepts/)
-   -   Truth Table of Not A Not B and Not (A and not B) (http://www.go4expert.com/forums/truth-table-b-b-t15710/)

Capparaceae 4Jan2009 04:45

Truth Table of Not A Not B and Not (A and not B)
 
This is a very impressive site with so many clever people amongst you. I'm trying to understand the work my granddaughter is doing so I can discuss it with her and help, but this defeats me. I know it's probably simple, but could someone please explain it to me. It's the brackets that I don't understand in the NOT(A AND NOT B)

Truth tables can be used to show whether or not two Boolean
expressions are equivalent. By copying (please make sure you copy
the first two columns exactly as shown) and completing the truth
tables given in Figure 5 below, show that
NOT A AND NOT B
is not equivalent to
NOT (A AND NOT B)
Make sure you end your answer with a proper conclusion.
[5]

shabbir 4Jan2009 05:05

Re: Hello Everyone Granny Needs Help!
 
I moved your thread into the right forum for better response and as I can see you are asking why

NOT A AND NOT B

and

NOT (A AND NOT B)

are not same and the reply lies in the bodmas rule of maths.

With the first statement the meaning is

Not of A and Not of B

Bit the second the statement is

A and Not Bs Not

xpi0t0s 4Jan2009 17:10

Re: Truth Table of Not A Not B and Not (A and not B)
 
Brackets are used specify the order of evaluation, just as in maths. 5 * 2 + 3 is 13 because multiplication takes precedence over addition, but if you wanted the addition first you'd write 5 * (2 + 3) which is 25.

It's the same with Boolean algebra. NOT A AND NOT B is the same as (NOT A) AND (NOT B), because NOT takes precedence, so NOT (A AND NOT B) just means that you want the inverse of A AND (NOT B).

To show that the two expressions are not equivalent basically this means that you must draw out the truth table for both. I find it easier to build it up with multiple columns rather than to try and work it all out for each line, so if the first column is A, the second B, the third NOT A, the fourth NOT B and the fifth the AND of the third and fourth, i.e. (NOT A) AND (NOT B), we get the following:
Code:

A B !A !B (!A . !B)
0 0  1  1  1
0 1  1  0  0
1 0  0  1  0
1 1  0  0  0

So do the same for NOT (A AND NOT B). Make the first two columns A and B, the third NOT B (just invert the second), the fourth A AND NOT B (so AND the 1st and 3rd) and the fifth the inverse of the fourth.

Capparaceae 5Jan2009 00:45

Re: Truth Table of Not A Not B and Not (A and not B)
 
I cannot thank you enough Shabbir for posting this one for me, as well as the explanation, also thank you xpi0tos for your help. I think I now understand.


All times are GMT +5.5. The time now is 14:02.