Sudoku | 21 Oct 2009

Go4Expert Founder
21Oct2009,22:06   #1
shabbir's Avatar
A sudoku where

First column sums to 15
Second column sums to 19
Third column sums to 11
Invasive contributor
21Oct2009,22:48   #2
nimesh's Avatar
Ideally in a game of sudoku sum of the numbers in all the columns are same.

5 3 1
6 7 2
4 9 8
Go4Expert Founder
22Oct2009,09:38   #3
shabbir's Avatar
See whats Sudoku - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sudoku
Invasive contributor
22Oct2009,10:43   #4
neo_vi's Avatar
sudoku has many variants. so which one does ur question belong to.? any clues?
Invasive contributor
22Oct2009,10:52   #5
neo_vi's Avatar
u didn't mention the number of grids. is it 3x3 or 9x9? give more detailed info for solving!
Mentor
22Oct2009,14:47   #6
xpi0t0s's Avatar
Quote:
Originally Posted by shabbir View Post
A sudoku where

First column sums to 15
Second column sums to 19
Third column sums to 11
...is non-existent, because by the rules of sudoku all columns contain one each of the digits 1-9 and therefore all columns add up to 45. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sudoku
Go4Expert Founder
22Oct2009,17:38   #7
shabbir's Avatar
I missed the trick. It was not 9x9 but 3x3 my mistake and so still would give nimesh as winner if no one else mind
Invasive contributor
22Oct2009,19:51   #8
nimesh's Avatar
@xpt: even I agree
but my answer was based on the que posted by shabbir

as per the competition rules,
Added 20th Jun 2009 - After all we are Human and if the poster does any mistake in question there would be no winner.
Invasive contributor
22Oct2009,19:53   #9
nimesh's Avatar
if the question was actually asked for sudoku, the question seems to be incorrect
Go4Expert Founder
23Oct2009,09:57   #10
shabbir's Avatar
Agreed