Nimesh had the 4 entries ( from the deleted post ) which were all done before 05:12
Nimesh's second entry was at 05:16 (which was right answer) and then added the descriptions till 05:24
Izaan, You posted at 05:24 where as Nimesh has multiple entries but they were all before 05:12. Definitely you saw the post and after counting made the post but he made the second final post before your and so Winner is Nimesh.
If you still have the doubts I can show you screenshots if needed.
Rules updated so that we do not allow edit / delete of posts in this forum so everyone can see the time stamps and entries of everybody.